October 5, 2010

The Pizza Delivery Chronicles, Part Two: Drivers at Risk

In yesterday's blog on this topic, we told the story of a pizza delivery driver whose undisclosed seizure problem put others (and herself) at risk. Today we examine the inordinate and ultimately terrifying risks that routinely confront the people who deliver pizzas to homes.

The risks of delivery jobs are embodied in one sad tale. Richel Nova, 58, was a hard working immigrant who worked two jobs, one being delivering pizzas for Domino's in Boston. He responded to a call from the Hyde Park neighborhood. The address was a vacant home. He was lured into the house, robbed, stabbed multiple times and left for dead. The three thieves took his money ($100) along with the pizza and drove off in his 1995 Subaru. (The age of the car tells us a lot about Mr. Nova.) The abandoned car was found a bit later, along with the blood-stained pizza box. All but three pieces had been eaten.

Nova's life revolved around his family: twin 20-year-old daughters and an older son. The twins are both juniors in college. All that stood between Nova and a seat at his daughters's graduation next year were a hundred bucks and a pizza to go.

Robberies of delivery people in the Boston area have been a long-standing problem - 52 were reported through mid-September.

Common Ground Among Competitors
The three main pizza chains - Domino's, Pizza Hut and Little Caesar's - have collaborated on developing safety programs for drivers. Among them, they have nearly 90,000 drivers on the road. (Here is the Domino's description of the job.) Statistically, it's not difficult to identify the riskiest neighborhoods for delivery, but the chains face pressure from neighborhood groups and the federal government to provide delivery services without discriminating against the poor.

Back in 2000, Domino's reached an agreement with the Justice Department to formalize a delivery policy for all its restaurants. Reflecting what Domino's said were well-established standard practices, the new guidelines require managers to evaluate crime statistics with local law enforcement agencies and community groups before limiting delivery. As part of that policy, drivers must report any incidences of violence, and delivery limits must be drawn narrowly. (Easier said than done.)

(Sort of) Managing Risk
There are a number of ideas floating around on how drivers should handle what appear to be risky delivery scenarios:
- Require the customer to come to the car to pay for the delivery and pick up the pizza. (This may not be feasible in all circumstances - for example, disabled customers may not be able to come to the street.)
- Require customers to have exact change for their purchase (and hope against hope that they have a bit extra for the tip!)
- Advise drivers not to enter darkened dwellings
- Limit deliveries after certain hours (in the Boston data mentioned above, many of the robberies took place after 9:00 pm.)
- When in doubt, when confronted with what appears to be immediate risk of harm, the driver is instructed to return to the store (and risk the wrath of legitimate, irate customers awaiting their dinners)

For those of us who have never had a gun or knife thrust into our faces, the dangers confronting delivery workers every day are both frightening and unimaginable. For Richal Nova's children, any mention of pizza will haunt their thoughts for the rest of their lives - reminding them of their father's lonely and senseless demise at the hands of cruel thugs with a half-baked plan for a free meal.



While the statistics may not be significantly different for 2010, the 52 robberies cited in the article were through mid-September 2007.

My question is what is the justice department doing in the pizza delivery business at all. What gives them any say in when and where a private business delivers.

If I was Domino's I would deliver where and when I wanted and if the justice department didn't like it tell them to pound sand.

They might come up with a way to put me out of business but it is cheaper than hiring armed guards to escort pizza drivers. I would never put anybody at risk because the justice department thinks they can tell me where to deliver and when.

That is INSANE. This is still the USA.


My whole family delivers pizza. This money normally goes for the household things that we need. It is really not much money. Without tips, it would not be worth it at all. The wear and tear on the car(s) is outrageous. Not to mention gas and cell minutes. I can't believe that these people had such disregard for life to rob a hard working man of his hard earned money. They come after me, they will be in for a rude awakening. Scum. Burn in hell. Disgusting. Trash. Earn your own money. And I don't mean by selling drugs. Again, trash. Sue


Submit your email to be notified when this site is updated

Need help with your workers' comp program?

Monthly Archives

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Jon Coppelman published on October 5, 2010 12:21 PM.

The Pizza Delivery Chronicles, Part One: Liability was the previous entry in this blog.

Cavalcade of Risk, #115 is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.

OpenID accepted here Learn more about OpenID