June 24, 2008

Injured and Illegal...in South Korea

We sometimes forget that the USA is not the only country with an undocumented worker problem. Anywhere you find developed countries with lots of (relatively high paying) jobs, you will find people willing to do anything to get them. Which leads us to an article in Korea Times by Park Si-soo.

Zhang Shuai, 22, entered South Korea on a student visa in March of 2005. He took a language course at a nearby university, but he also began working (illegally) at an electronics firm in a neighboring city. In May 2006, immigration officials raided the building (shades of last year's ICE raids in New Bedford). His employer told Zhang to skedaddle pronto (using, of course, the Korean equivalent). During his flight, he accidentally fell from the building, suffering brain damage and paralysis in his left arm and leg.

Zhang filed for the South Korean equivalent of workers comp benefits. His initial petition was denied, because "his escape had nothing to do with his duties at work." But the Busan High Court has granted Zhang compensation for his injuries. The court is able to connect the dots between Zhang's job duties and his escape attempt (please excuse the rather byzantine grammar, a product, perhaps, of hasty translation):

His escape attempt was to avoid many disadvantages that he would receive after the inspection, but it is also true that his employers forced him to escape so as to continue their operations because they were not able to find local workers despite repeated recruitment advertisements. Therefore, the escape was part of his duties at work.

There are several seemingly universal principles here: people will gravitate to available work with minimal consideration of national boundaries or workrules; undocumented workers will be injured on the job with the same or higher frequency of regular workers; in most instances, undocumented workers will be eligible for workers comp or its equivalent.

We have an undocumented worker problem in this country of humongous proportions, but we are by no means alone. Perhaps the United Nations could come up with a solution that attacks this problem not just in the US, but across the entire world. Just kidding. That would imply a rational and universal approach to shared problems. No way, Jose! It is far more likely that undocumented workers will continue to break the rules and continue to do the work, country by country, across the face of the earth.



Excellent posting. there are 150 million people who have crossed national boundaries to seek work, and there are about 150 million people who have migrated internally to seek work (many of the latter in China and India). Right now, 14% of the Mexican workforce is working in the U.S. These figures give you a sense of the scale of the entire process of immigrant labor and how the U.S. fits into it.

Oh -- and about $50billion is remitted every year by workers back to their home countries.


It is interesting to see we are not alone and Peter illustrates that even better.

As to "Perhaps the United Nations could come up with a solution that attacks this problem not just in the US, but across the entire world."

There is a solution already in place.

"Obey the law."

It is codified into every nation's laws and every major religion I know of. People just don't obey the law because the consequences of not doing so are not perceived as being high enough. I promise you if they started hanging illegal aliens and the person who employed them in the town square, the vast majority of illegal immigration would come to a screeching halt.

I am not recommending hanging, just making a point about encouraging people to obey the law.



Submit your email to be notified when this site is updated

Need help with your workers' comp program?

Monthly Archives

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Jon Coppelman published on June 24, 2008 10:41 AM.

Google throws its hat into the electronic medical records arena was the previous entry in this blog.

9/11 Rescuers: Fools Rush In...? is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.

OpenID accepted here Learn more about OpenID