July 29, 2005

Summer Hire Turns Tragic

A little over a year ago we cautioned employers to be careful with summer hires. Make sure summer hires are qualified to do the work. Don't allow them to operate heavy equipment. And perhaps most important, don't just "toss them the keys" when driving is required.

Today we read in the New York Times (registratoin required) of a tragic accident in upstate New York. A car full of aspiring dancers was on its way to a lake for a swim. The driver sped along narrow roads, reaching speeds of 80 mph or more, until she lost control and slammed into a county dump truck. The small Toyota disintegrated upon impact, killing six people, the driver and five youngsters.

It turns out that the driver, 25-year-old Irina Mironova of Miami Beach, Fla., had a suspended Florida license for driving more than 100 mph. To be sure, many people get speeding tickets, but how many involve going 107 mph? This is a blatant case of negligent entrustment: Mironova should never have been allowed to drive. Not only did she have a poor driving record, if asked, she could not have produced a valid license.

I have no idea what the finances for running a small camp in the Catskills are like, but the camp would be required to carry liability insurance. In addition to suffering the pain of losing her youngest son, the camp's owner, Anna Kapitannikov, in all likelihood faces protracted legal actions for this single act of negligence. For lack of a simple check on her counselors's licenses, her life and her business are in ruins.

Due Diligence
Good management takes nothing for granted. The fact that someone is 25 and knows how to drive does not mean you can trust them behind the wheel. A little due diligence is always in order. For the few moments that might take, you could be spared a lifetime of grief.



That accident occurred about 30 miles from me and was certainly a tragedy for all involved, including the rescue workers. I've noticed many young drivers in our area driving in this manner, I'd like to think this would be wakeup call, but doubt it.

I agree about the camp, it'll be tough time sfor a while, if they make it.

Sadly many insurance brokers and organization leaders view driving record checks and updates as an "invasion of privacy" (even when the driving is required for work). This leaves the insurance carrier/underwriter in an awkward position. Sadly, many employer organizations do not understand the liability they are exposing their members to by not encouraging sound risk management practices (i.e driving record checks and subscription to driving record updates)

A key is to do an initial check and then subscribe all driver to the "pull notice" system managed by many states like California. It is well worth the small expense.

A risk manager who has "been there"

i knoe them personallii...and irina was a great person..and i still dun understand y she would do dat...and no no1 can still get over dis car crash...their names were Gaby 12, Anatoli 14 turing 15, masha 14, ilya 16, and igor 16 and irina 25...da camp was great and was a lot of fun it was my 3rd year there
i'll never forget them...rest in peace...Gabby, Masha, Ilya, Anatoly, Igor, and Irina-July-27-2005


Submit your email to be notified when this site is updated

Need help with your workers' comp program?

Monthly Archives

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Jon Coppelman published on July 29, 2005 2:21 PM.

Healthcare weblogs added to our sidebar was the previous entry in this blog.

The Costco story: good employers get good results is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.

OpenID accepted here Learn more about OpenID